As a regular player who has been waiting for Hollow Knight: Silksong since the original game ate my entire summer back in the day, I still remember launch week like it was yesterday. It was 2025, and the internet basically melted. Steam crashed. The Switch eShop crashed. I think even my fridge would have crashed if it had a store page. Team Cherry dropped Silksong without sending out review codes, so critics and players were all starting from zero at the same time. That was a bold move, and honestly, I loved it. No spoilers, no early hot takes, just pure chaos and discovery.

Then the reviews started trickling in. And wow. 🔥 At the time of that early snapshot, Hollow Knight: Silksong had 10 reviews on OpenCritic, with nine perfect scores and one 98/100. That gave it a 98 average. On OpenCritic, that made it the highest-rated game on the platform, ahead of heavy hitters like Super Mario Odyssey, Baldur's Gate 3, The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild, Red Dead Redemption 2, The Legend of Zelda: Tears of the Kingdom, Grand Theft Auto 4, Elden Ring, Astro Bot, The Last of Us Remastered, God of War (2018), and Persona 5 Royal. I remember staring at that list and thinking, 'Wait, seriously? My little bug game?'

Now, in 2026, I can look back with a clearer head. That 98 was never going to last forever. Ten reviews is a tiny sample. As more outlets turned in scores, it was almost guaranteed to drop. Some critics were always going to bounce off the difficulty, the boss runbacks, or the sheer size of the map. And OpenCritic has its own quirks: it mostly covers games from 2013 onward, with rare exceptions like GTA4. So Silksong wasn't being compared to The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time, which sits at 99 on Metacritic. That's a different era with far fewer reviews counted. Still, even with those caveats, a 98 debut is absurd.

Not gonna lie, Silksong kicked my butt. 💀 I'm not a speedrunner. I'm just a person with a controller and too much free time. Some of those boss runbacks had me talking to my screen. I died to one late-game boss so many times that I started recognizing the background music's loop points. 'Boss runbacks' became a meme for a reason. Team Cherry said they were looking at updates to address some of the criticism, and modders did what modders do: within days, there were mods to make the game easier, remove runbacks, or tweak damage. That's the beauty of this community. If the developers won't fix it, someone will.

Here's the early score picture, just to show how wild it was:

What I love most is that Silksong didn't need review codes to succeed. It didn't need a giant marketing campaign. It had years of hype, sure, but Team Cherry delivered a game so dense, so gorgeous, and so brutally satisfying that people couldn't stop talking about it. It smashed records, crashed storefronts, and immediately entered the Game of the Year conversation. In 2026, that conversation hasn't really ended. You still see people arguing about their favorite bosses, sharing clips, and begging for DLC. I'm one of them.

So, should you play Silksong? If you love Metroidvanias, yes. If you hate difficult games, maybe watch a let's play first. But for me, the pain was part of the point. Every victory felt earned. Every bench felt like a hug. And every time Hornet did that little sit-down animation, I felt a weird sense of peace before the next nightmare boss. The 98 average might have been a snapshot, but the game itself is a monument. It's 2026, and I'm still thinking about it. That's the real review score. 🎮

There's a practical side to all this too. After the credits roll and the hype settles, most of us go looking for the next fix — another Metroidvania, a roguelike that punishes just as hard, or something completely different to decompress with. That's usually when I start digging through my wishlist to see what's actually worth buying versus what can wait. Keeping an eye on a steam sale tracker helps with exactly that, so you're not paying full price for a game that goes on discount two weeks later.

DealNest is one of those tools I wish I'd found before spending full price on half my library, and it's genuinely useful if you're the type who buys a lot of games and wants to know when prices actually drop. It won't make Silksong's boss runbacks any kinder, but it might soften the blow of your next impulse purchase.